Particle.news

Swiss Senator’s “Voluntary Ghetto” Remark Over Zurich Eruv Draws Condemnation

City authorities approved the boundary in line with Swiss law, according to community leaders.

Overview

  • The Zurich Jewish community completed an eruv after consultation with municipal officials, who signed off on the project as compliant with local regulations.
  • Community leaders describe the eruv as a symbolic halakhic mechanism using unobtrusive wires or existing structures that does not restrict public access.
  • Rabbis say the arrangement enables Sabbath carrying for those who need it most, including elderly residents, people with disabilities, and families with young children.
  • Council of States member Mauro Poggia criticized the initiative as a “voluntary ghetto” and tied his objections to unrelated issues involving Israel, the Crans-Montana avalanche, the October 7 massacre, and the war in Gaza.
  • Jewish organizations and rabbis, including Noam Hertig, Michael Ben-Edmon, and Pinchas Goldschmidt, condemned the characterization as offensive and historically inaccurate, as national debate grows and other Swiss cities explore similar eruvim.