Particle.news

Six Colors Report Card Finds Apple Hardware Strong as Software Scores Sink on macOS Tahoe Backlash

A 56-member panel reports widespread year-over-year declines, including an F on world impact.

Overview

  • Operating system quality averaged 2.7 and first‑party app quality 3.1, both down from last year’s 3.4 and 3.5.
  • Hardware reliability led at 4.5, reinforcing sustained praise for Apple’s devices across recent years.
  • Panelists cited macOS 26 Tahoe’s Liquid Glass redesign as a key driver of the Mac’s lower score, with prominent commentators issuing harsh critiques.
  • Scores fell in 11 of 14 categories overall, while iPhone and iPad each rose 0.2 points on product and software improvements.
  • The “Impact on the World” rating dropped a full point to an F, which several panelists linked to Tim Cook’s stance toward the Trump administration.