Particle.news

Materialists Earns Accolades for Visual Style and Dating Critique, Draws Criticism for Tone

Critics highlight the film’s lush portrayal of Manhattan’s dating economy, turning modern matchmaking into a market of measured values

Overview

  • Materialists, Celine Song’s sophomore feature, follows Lucy, a Manhattan matchmaker played by Dakota Johnson, as she navigates a choice between wealthy client Harry (Pedro Pascal) and ex-boyfriend John (Chris Evans).
  • Reviewers uniformly praise Shabier Kirchner’s cinematography and the film’s lush, honeyed visuals that cast Manhattan’s elite dating scene in a golden glow.
  • Many critics commend the film’s sharp critique of dating commodification and its candid dialogue on financial and superficial criteria in modern relationships.
  • Some reviewers criticize the film’s uneven tone, citing awkward chemistry among the leads and an abrupt sexual assault subplot that disrupts narrative momentum.
  • Song’s own mid-2010s experience as a New York matchmaker underpins the film’s frank exploration of matchmaking as a transactional business.